Shorty's Pizza

Shorty's has the best NY style pizza in Hamilton. Their crust is delicious, with a bit of honey.
I don't know what's happened in the last few months though. I don't recognize any of the staff. The last time I went, they told us it would be "at least an hour" for a 14" pepperoni. There was no one eating in. There was one guy making pizza and one lady working the cash. Shorty's needs more staff.
The second last time we went, they messed up our order. When we asked about it, they told us we had to pay more. Shorty's needs better service.
I hope Shorty's fixes this because their pizza is to die for. Unfortunately, amazing pizza can only get you so far if you give out a bad customer experience.

Excellent pizza and very helpful staff. Really delicious sauce and fresh ingredients. I have tried both the arugula and caesar salads and both are good. Good beer selection too.

The wait times can be a bit long only because they are very popular - not unreasonably long but up to 45 minutes in my experience. The restaurant is casual and comfortable, lots of natural light pouring in through the front windows, and comfortable seating; not at all crowded so it is easy to move around. Parking around the restaurant can be a bit tight but this is Hamilton after all.

A great place to go for a slice! Staff is friendly and can be seen making the pizza behind the counter. There's lots of room if you want to dine in. Also they have a surprising beer selection. Pizzas taste great; some of the best the city has to offer.

Stopped in at the recommendation of a family member and unfortunately had to wait almost 45 mins for a pizza, but it was well worth it! Ingredients were fresh tasting, high quality, and well balanced on the pizza. It was a little cold after I got home, about a 10 min drive, but as a thin crust, it was expected. I also got the dough knots, which were sweet, but with a solid spicy kick to them.

This place is just amazing. The pizza here is incredible. They use a perfect combination of ingredients and manage to do something a little different to provide a pizza that is like nothing else I have ever tried. After almost 40 years that's no mean feat. The location has about half a dozen tables for eating in and delivers through skip the dishes and Uber eats as well. I highly recommend any pizza with hot honey on it. Try this place out, trust me you won't regret it.