Pie Guys Pizzeria

Ordered two 12 sliced pizzas & wings, all toppings were fresh the sauce & cheese were perfect! They went above and beyond for me on a busy Friday night. Pizza was hot fresh out of the oven and didn't last long at my house. Wings were a beautiful size, cooked perfectly and medium buffalo sauced flawlessly.
The staff was working so hard and good together , I am really happy for this new location. Staff was also soooo friendly to me treated me like family although this was my first time here, the first of MANY visits! Thank you Pie Guys Fonthil, owners and staff.

I do not usually like to write a bad review, but we are highly disappointed in this place. We ordered a pizza at 3:45 today for a 6pm pickup, and my husband had to wait outside for halve an hour tonight before it was ready.
There were only 7 wings in the order, for $12.00. We were not given celery and blue cheese. The barbecue chicken pizza was missing the sauce on the crust!!! Someone had drizzled a bit of sauce on the top of the pizza. Did someone forget to put sauce on the pizza, or is that how you make it?? Also what was the purpose in us ordering two hours in advance, only to wait in the cold for 35 minutes? Good luck to you guys!

We recently moved to Welland and have been trying many of the pizza places, and Pie Guys is by far one of the best places out there! The pizza was so good! There was plenty of fresh toppings, and it had really good flavour. The chicken wings were delicious - we tried the honey/hot and the medium buffalo. Both had really good flavours and were good sizes and crispy. I highly recommend this place for people looking to have great tasting food. Its definitely worth the few extra pennies compared to the cheaper pizza places that have watery soggy pizza with no toppings and soggy wings. 5/5 stars