The Seafood Shack

Great find next to the gas station.

Lobster rolls were great, love the dill! Had the homemade lemonade and strawberry shortcake. Both great. Fries were also amazing, crispy with plenty of salt and pepper.

Mixed feelings on this place. Lobster roll was good, we tried the Holy Aioli. Kids enjoyed their chicken fingers. Lobster poutine toppings were fine but a word of caution they are now serving frozen Cavendish fries, despite the signs still saying “hand cut fries”. This was definitely a disappointment as we came here for a special occasion on our way to the beach. It’s totally fair if a business chooses to serve frozen fries but I think the menu needs to be truthful / not misleading.

I want to commend the owner for actually taking the time to listen to my feedback and offering some compensation for part of our order. She did not have to do that and the gesture was appreciated. If you go back to serving real fries we would be thrilled to try it again on a future trip.

Fresh lobster in a bun... what more could you ask for? We tried the Strait Up with just melted butter and the Holy Aioli with a garlic aioli. Fries are great too... well worth the trip.

Lobster wrap and lobster roll were the most delicious that we'd ever had.
Opted for the chowder to go - glad we did!!! Giant pieces of seafood 😋

I would drive across the island for this hidden gem!! The fish and chips were the best I’ve ever had and well priced. The lobster rolls also a must try!