Insomnia Cookies

Very quick and easy fix for your sweet tooth. Not to bad besides the cookie being undercooked and barely crispy which is how I prefer a cookie. Next time I’ll try a few different kinds to see what the hype is. I say stick at home and buy a pre-made batter from Toll house with extra chocolate and it’ll be cooked to your liking. Not worth the $3.60 in my opinion

I absolutely LOVE this place! My wife always talked about the food truck when she went to school in Philly and the new Buffalo/Amherst location does not disappoint! My favorite is the triple chocolate chunk, and it’s always consistent and delicious.

Would've been 3☆'s if it hadn't been for the cashier saluting us on the way out. Cookies were good, but not amazing. I wouldn't do anything crazy for them like I would for a klondike bar.

Glad that the cookies and ice cream tastes great! Just like NYC. Favorite ice cream flavor is their ‘cuse 44 flavor!
Dropped a star rating because customer service could be better. It doesn’t cost anything to smile or greet your customers.

Employees should be better trained in customer service for sure. (Only the girl who worked at night was very nice!)

I don’t know anything about the delivery service yet. But will update review once I try it out.

My husband just ordered a couple cookiewich's for delivery. It said 20-35 minutes for delivery, I placed the order at 7:30 & 20 minutes later the driver was pulling up in front of our house with warm cookies and cold ice cream! The cookies were delicious and they give a generous amount of ice cream for a reasonable cost considering they are fresh baked, warm cookies! My favorite part is that I got to choose what kind of cookies (and could pick two different kinds) plus the type of ice cream to truly customize my ice cream cookiewich! I will definitely be ordering from here again to fulfill my cookie fix needs!