Bagel Jay's Bakery & Cafe

Want a real NYC bagel? No - not a tiny supermarket bagel. No - not a soft mushy Tommy Ho's. No - not a plain Jane Dunkin. But a real crisp, fresh, delicious NYC-style bagel? Go here. Seriously - go here no matter what you want. Oh and by the way, if you've got a 2 year granddaughter - get her a cinnamon sticks bagel!

Bagel Jay's is the best. The bagels are so fresh, you can really taste the difference. Everything we've had for breakfast and lunch has been great and the people are always friendly and genuinely nice.

Wonderful bagels, lots of cream cheese which I personally love. My only issue is they have so many varieties, yet they no longer have egg bagels. Far too many, what I would call, novelty flavors, yet a classic egg bagel is not on the menu is a massive disappointment.

This is one of the best places for bagels in Buffalo. My favorite is honestly just a plain bagel toasted with butter. They have good coffee with a variety of flavors (my favorite is hazelnut or the dark roast) as well as a bunch of other drinks like bottled tea and juice. They also have fresh baked goods and their chocolate chip cookies are exceptionally good.